For Groundhog Day, PETA Wants to Replace Phil With This Twist on a Gender Reveal Party

Since the late 1800s, some Pennsylvania men in suits and top hats have looked to a groundhog to predict the bitterness of the winter ahead after February. The groundhog is called Punxsutawney Phil, so-named after the town in Pennsylvania where this bizarre and cruel annual tradition occurs.

Each year, the severity of winter weather over the next several weeks is purportedly contingent upon a frightened groundhog being presented to large crowds in sub-freezing temperatures after seeing (or not seeing) their shadow.

Enter PETA, an organization that has long been critical of the Punxsutawney, Pa. tradition, and the group's latest plea to let the poor animal be— which involve a twist on a gender reveal party tradition.

In January 2025, PETA sent a letter to the Punxsutawney Groundhog Club, offering to supply the club with a unique "weather reveal" vegan cake. The animal protection organization told president Tom Dunkel that if he promises to permanently send Punxsutawney Phil and his family to an animal sanctuary, then PETA will provide the club with a new vegan weather reveal cake every year.

In PETA's proposal, the cake would be cut every Groundhog Day to reveal either a pink filling (meaning an early spring) or a blue filling (meaning six more weeks of winter).

“When allowed to be themselves, groundhogs avoid humans, create intricate networks of underground burrows, communicate with one another, and even climb trees, but poor Phil is denied all of that for a tired old gimmick,” PETA President Ingrid Newkirk said in a statement.

In January 2024, PETA offered to send the Groundhog Club's president and related officials a giant gold coin — symbolic, the group says, because a groundhog's prediction is no more reliable than the flip of a coin.

"Groundhogs can't make heads or tails of the weather forecast and shouldn't be jostled around by large members of a different species and thrust in front of noisy crowds for a photo op," PETA President Ingrid Newkirk stated at the time.

Previous Groundhog Day traditions included digging up a poor groundhog from their home, being chased by townspeople, and having a "magical elixir" of "vodka, milk, and orange juice" shoved down their throats, with their kin hunted and eaten in celebration, per History.

Though the "elixir of life" has not been used for more than a century, per TIME, the unbridled cruelty of each successive groundhog's handling remains.

According to PETA, Phil is not treated like royalty throughout the remainder of the year but rather confined to a small enclosure in a library year-round.

In PETA's letter to Groundhog Club President Tom Dunkel, they acknowledged the storied history of the tradition, while urging a humane future for Phil.

"Give Phil the retirement party he deserves, complete with a ticket to a reputable sanctuary, and we’ll send you a two-sided giant coin to forecast the weather in his place. This makes cents for several reasons," the letter read.

Organizations such as Farm Sanctuary have protested against the exploitation of these fuzzy creatures for human entertainment, suggesting that groundhog enthusiasts instead take action against government programs and "traditions" that kill wildlife.

Past PETA proposals for Western Pennsylvania's Groundhog Day tradition alternatives include a persimmon tree, an animatronic Phil who could predict the weather more accurately utilizing artificial intelligence, and replacing Phil with a human activist who would live in Phil's enclosure instead.

Phil is far from the only groundhog used for human entertainment and unreliable weather forecasting. In fact, per the Countdown to Groundhog Day website, many other states in the U.S. and areas around the world look to live groundhogs, stuffed animal versions, and taxidermied groundhogs for their winter predictions.

And, according to an illuminating USA Today graphic, Phil's 40 percent accuracy in predicting the weather is, in fact, no more reliable than a flip of the coin.

This article, originally published on Feb. 1, 2024, has been updated.